This topic contains a solution. Click here to go to the answer

Author Question: How would a cognitive dissonance theorist counter the Freudian argument that catharsisblowing off ... (Read 75 times)

ghost!

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 560
How would a cognitive dissonance theorist counter the Freudian argument that catharsisblowing off steam to relieve the buildup of destructive aggressive impulseswill reduce aggression?
 
  Use an example of yelling or using sarcasm to vent our anger at someone who has angered us.
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

Your six-year-old brother has developed some very distressing habits. He has become increasingly aggressive, destroying toys, hitting the neighbors' children, and threatening them with violence to take their toys away.
 
  You want to stop your little brother's destructive behavior using punishment. What would be the best way to do this?



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
Marked as best answer by a Subject Expert

lorealeza77

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 356
Answer to Question 1

Answer: Dissonance theorists would argue that because people often engage in overkill when they are angered, a vicious spiral of aggression, self-justification, and more destructive aggression is likely to result. For example, when we verbally vent our anger or use sarcasm as a weapon against someone, it can be hurtful to them, and is at odds with our self-concepts as kind and reasonable people. Because we cannot undo this behavior, we will seek to preserve our self-esteem internally by convincing ourselves that the target of our anger must have deserved it. Once we use derogation to justify our verbal aggression, it becomes easier and easier to justify more destructive aggressive acts against them.

Answer to Question 2

Answer: First, because severe physical punishment can boomerang by teaching children that aggression is appropriate, it is best not to use severe physical punishment such as slapping or spanking. Threats of severe punishment would not be likely to work; such severe threats might provide your brother with external justification for refraining from hitting, throwing, and he will be unlikely to convince himself that such behavior is undesirable. To use punishment appropriately, it is important to remain vigilant around your little brother, and to make swift and reasonable interventions such as time-outs. It would also help to model nonaggressive alternatives for dealing with frustration and conflict.





 

Did you know?

As the western states of America were settled, pioneers often had to drink rancid water from ponds and other sources. This often resulted in chronic diarrhea, causing many cases of dehydration and death that could have been avoided if clean water had been available.

Did you know?

No drugs are available to relieve parathyroid disease. Parathyroid disease is caused by a parathyroid tumor, and it needs to be removed by surgery.

Did you know?

Street names for barbiturates include reds, red devils, yellow jackets, blue heavens, Christmas trees, and rainbows. They are commonly referred to as downers.

Did you know?

It is widely believed that giving a daily oral dose of aspirin to heart attack patients improves their chances of survival because the aspirin blocks the formation of new blood clots.

Did you know?

The highest suicide rate in the United States is among people ages 65 years and older. Almost 15% of people in this age group commit suicide every year.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library