This topic contains a solution. Click here to go to the answer

Author Question: What role does the concept of cointegration and the order of integration play in modeling the ... (Read 267 times)

bobthebuilder

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 567
What role does the concept of cointegration and the order of integration play in modeling the relationship between variables? Explain how tests of cointegration work.
 
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

One should never bother with WLS. Using OLS with robust standard errors gives correct inference, at least asymptotically. True, false, or a bit of both? Explain carefully what the quote means and evaluate it critically.
 
  What will be an ideal response?



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
Marked as best answer by a Subject Expert

millet

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 354
Answer to Question 1

Answer: Cointegration between two or more variables is a regression analysis concept to potentially reveal long-run relationships among time series variables. Variables are said to be cointegrated if the have the same stochastic trend in common. Most economic time series are I(1) variables, which means that they have a unit autoregressive root and that the first difference in that variable is stationary. Since these variables are often measured in logs, their first difference approximates growth rates. Cointegration requires a common stochastic trend. Therefore, variables which are tested for cointegration must have the same order of integration.

The concept of cointegration is also an effort to bring back long-run relationships between variables into short-run forecasting techniques, such as VARs. Adding the error correction term from the cointegrating relationship to the VARs results in the vector error correction model. Here all variables are stationary, either because they have been differenced or because the common stochastic trend has been removed. VECMs therefore combine short-run and long-run information. One way to think about the role of the error correction term is that it provides an anchor which pulls the modeled relationships eventually back to their long-run behavior, even if it is disturbed by shocks in the short-run.

Cointegration also represents the return of the static regression model, i.e., regressions where no lags or used. To test for cointegration using the EG-ADF test requires estimating a static regression between the potentially cointegrated variables by OLS first, and then to conduct an ADF test on the residuals from this regression. If the residuals do not have a unit root, then the variables are said to be cointegrated. Since this is a two step procedure, critical values for the ADF t-statistic are adjusted and are referred to the critical values for the EG-ADF statistic. Although the OLS estimator is consistent, it has a nonnormal distribution and hence inference should not be conducted based on the t-statistic, even if HAC standard errors are used. Alternative techniques to circumvent this problem, such as the DOLS estimator, which is consistent and efficient in large samples, have been developed. The DOLS and another frequently used technique, called the Johansen method, can be easily extended to multiple cointegrating relationships.

Answer to Question 2

Answer: WLS is a special case of the GLS estimator. Furthermore, OLS is a special case of the WLS estimator. Both will produce different estimates of the intercept and the coefficients of the other regressors, and different estimates of their standard errors. WLS has the advantage over OLS, that it is (asymptotically) more efficient than OLS. However, the efficiency result depends on knowing the conditional variance function. When this is the case, the parameters can be estimated and the weights can be specified. Unfortunately in practice, as Stock and Watson put it, the functional form of the conditional variance function is rarely known. Using an incorrect functional form for the estimation of the parameters results in incorrect statistical inference. The bottom line is that WLS should be used in those rare instances where the functional form is known, but not otherwise. Estimation of the parameters using OLS with heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors, on the other hand, leads to asymptotically valid inferences even for the case where the functional form of the heteroskedasticity is not known. It therefore seems that for real world applications the above statement is true.




bobthebuilder

  • Member
  • Posts: 567
Reply 2 on: Jun 29, 2018
Excellent


blakcmamba

  • Member
  • Posts: 335
Reply 3 on: Yesterday
Gracias!

 

Did you know?

It is difficult to obtain enough calcium without consuming milk or other dairy foods.

Did you know?

There used to be a metric calendar, as well as metric clocks. The metric calendar, or "French Republican Calendar" divided the year into 12 months, but each month was divided into three 10-day weeks. Each day had 10 decimal hours. Each hour had 100 decimal minutes. Due to lack of popularity, the metric clocks and calendars were ended in 1795, three years after they had been first marketed.

Did you know?

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) was originally known as the Communicable Disease Center, which was formed to fight malaria. It was originally headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia, since the Southern states faced the worst threat from malaria.

Did you know?

About 600,000 particles of skin are shed every hour by each human. If you live to age 70 years, you have shed 105 pounds of dead skin.

Did you know?

The newest statin drug, rosuvastatin, has been called a superstatin because it appears to reduce LDL cholesterol to a greater degree than the other approved statin drugs.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library