Author Question: Which of the following techniques can a reviewer use for assistance when critiquing a published ... (Read 49 times)

wrbasek0

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 560
Which of the following techniques can a reviewer use for assistance when critiquing a published study in the area of theory and research frameworks?
 
  a. Develop an expertise in a particular statistical method to improve analysis ability.
  b. Creating a conceptual map of the concepts as described in the study.
  c. Reading other research reports to familiarize oneself with the concepts being studied.
  d. Writing a well thought-out and well-written study.

Question 2

What is the best skill to use in distinguishing statements expressed as propositions from hypotheses?
 
  a. A checklist created from the details of the study
  b. A list of questions that can identify one from the other
  c. The precise definitions of each kind of statement
  d. Use of critical thinking



Kingjoffery

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 332
Answer to Question 1

ANS: B
Creating a conceptual map from the concepts as described in the study will assist the reviewer in understanding the relationships the researcher is proposing between the concepts under study.
The reviewers does not need to develop an expertise in any particular statistical method to improve analysis ability; rather the reviewer needs to be able to discern if the statistical methods used are appropriate for the questions posed, and if the report is clearly written.
While having a broader knowledge on the concepts being studied may assist the reviewer in understanding the concepts being studied in the current report being reviewed, it is not necessary.
Writing a well thought-out study is the goal of the researcher. The goal of the reviewer is to be able to effectively evaluate whether a research report is well written and that the research has usefulness for clinical practice.

Answer to Question 2

ANS: D
Using critical reasoning is the best way to identify propositions from hypotheses.
Checklists do not exist for the distinguishing propositions from hypotheses within a study. Using critical reasoning is the best way to identify propositions from hypotheses.
A list of questions will help, but it is critical reasoning that best differentiates. Using critical reasoning is the best way to identify propositions from hypotheses.
The definitions indicate a certain degree of abstraction. Using critical reasoning is the best way to identify propositions from hypotheses.



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
 

Did you know?

Many supplement containers do not even contain what their labels say. There are many documented reports of products containing much less, or more, that what is listed on their labels. They may also contain undisclosed prescription drugs and even contaminants.

Did you know?

About 80% of major fungal systemic infections are due to Candida albicans. Another form, Candida peritonitis, occurs most often in postoperative patients. A rare disease, Candida meningitis, may follow leukemia, kidney transplant, other immunosuppressed factors, or when suffering from Candida septicemia.

Did you know?

Over time, chronic hepatitis B virus and hepatitis C virus infections can progress to advanced liver disease, liver failure, and hepatocellular carcinoma. Unlike other forms, more than 80% of hepatitis C infections become chronic and lead to liver disease. When combined with hepatitis B, hepatitis C now accounts for 75% percent of all cases of liver disease around the world. Liver failure caused by hepatitis C is now leading cause of liver transplants in the United States.

Did you know?

Addicts to opiates often avoid treatment because they are afraid of withdrawal. Though unpleasant, with proper management, withdrawal is rarely fatal and passes relatively quickly.

Did you know?

When blood is exposed to air, it clots. Heparin allows the blood to come in direct contact with air without clotting.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library