Author Question: Which of the following represent the specific attributes that qualitative research must possess in ... (Read 45 times)

sheilaspns · **on:** Jul 8, 2018

Which of the following represent the specific attributes that qualitative research must possess in order to be evaluated as acceptable? (Select all that apply.)

a. Intellectual contribution
b. Methodological congruence
c. Evaluative strength
d. Philosophical congruence
e. Suspension of disbelief
f. Intuitive comprehension

Question 2

What happens during the second step of the quantitative critical appraisal process, in the case in which the reader determines study strengths and weaknesses of a particularly weak research report?

a. The reader discovers what elements of the study are in what locations of the report.
b. The reader constructs a global appraisal of the research's lack of rigor.
c. The reader's task is to analyze the quality of the individual parts of a research report. This inevitably produces an impression not only of what the research did not do, but also of what should have been done.
d. The reader is required to examine each part minutely; this leads to an appreciation of what the researcher did well.
e. The reader evaluates the goodness of the study.

jaymee143 · **Reply #1 on:** Jul 8, 2018

Answer to Question 1

ANS: A, B, D, F
Critical appraisal is not complete with making judgments about the validity of the study. Synthesis of the evaluative criteria for qualitative studies can be reframed as philosophical congruence, methodological coherence, intuitive comprehension, and intellectual contribution.

Answer to Question 2

ANS: C, D

The critical appraisal process for quantitative research includes three steps: (1) identifying the steps of the research process, (2) determining study strengths and weaknesses, and (3) evaluating the credibility and meaning of a study to nursing knowledge and practice. Identification of the steps of the research process in a quantitative study is the first step in critical appraisal. The next step in critically appraising a quantitative study requires determining the strengths and weaknesses of the study. To do this, the reader must have knowledge of what each step of the research process should be like from expert sources, such as this textbook and other research sources. Then the ideal ways to conduct the steps of the research process are compared with the actual study steps. During this comparison, the reader examines the extent to which the researcher followed the rules for an ideal study.