When did carnatic music begin to take its present shape? List the ...

[nmorano1]

When did carnatic music begin to take its present shape? List the three great saint-poet-composers of this period. Whose songs dominate the repertoire today?
 
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

What are the similarities and differences between music of the classical Hindusthani style of North India and the classical music of the Carnatic style of South India?
 
  What will be an ideal response?

[ankilker]

Answer to Question 1

• The golden age of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries.


• Syama Sastry (1762  1827), Tyagaraja (1767  1847), and

Muttuswamy Dikshitar (1776  1836)

• Tyagaraja's songs dominate the repertoire today


• because of the accessibility of both their poetry and music.

Answer to Question 2

• Similarities: Both styles use ragas (melodic mode/system) and talas (metric cycle).


• Differences: In the Hindusthani style of North India expansive improvisations move gradually from near immobility to sections of great speed and virtuosity.

Carnatic music of the south is built around an immense repertoire of pre-composed Hindu devotional songs. The musical texture is busier, and improvisations fall within block-like sections.

[nmorano1]

Gracias!

[sailorcrescent]

Thanks for the timely response, appreciate it