« previous next »

Author Question: Explain the impact resulting from the selective reporting of statistical results by the ... (Read 91 times)

PhilipSeeMore

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 561
on: Jul 24, 2018
Explain the impact resulting from the selective reporting of statistical results by the media.

Question 2

Suppose a researcher conducts 100 hypothesis tests on her large data set and reports on the five results that were found to be significant, but doesn't inform the reader about the other 95 tests that were done. Is there a problem with this? Explain why or why not.


blakcmamba

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 335
Reply #1 on: Jul 24, 2018
Answer to Question 1

THE MEDIA LIKES TO SELECTIVELY REPORT THE MOST INTERESTING/SHOCKING RESULTS; WHEN THEY LEAVE OUT THE INFORMATION ON LESS INTERESTING STUDIES OR RESULTS, THEY ARE CREATING BIAS IN THEIR REPORTING OF RESEARCH RESULTS, AND ARE TAKING RESULTS OUT OF CONTEXT. THIS IS NOT ETHICAL.

.

Answer to Question 2

YES. EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING REASONS IS OK: 1) IT IS UNETHICAL NOT TO GIVE READERS THE WHOLE PICTURE; 2) CHANCE ALONE WOULD GIVE YOU 5 SIGNIFICANT RESULTS OUT OF 100 TESTS ON AVERAGE, SO HER RESULTS COULD VERY WELL BE MEANINGLESS.


Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
« previous next »
 

Did you know?

The training of an anesthesiologist typically requires four years of college, 4 years of medical school, 1 year of internship, and 3 years of residency.

Did you know?

GI conditions that will keep you out of the U.S. armed services include ulcers, varices, fistulas, esophagitis, gastritis, congenital abnormalities, inflammatory bowel disease, enteritis, colitis, proctitis, duodenal diverticula, malabsorption syndromes, hepatitis, cirrhosis, cysts, abscesses, pancreatitis, polyps, certain hemorrhoids, splenomegaly, hernias, recent abdominal surgery, GI bypass or stomach stapling, and artificial GI openings.

Did you know?

In 2006, a generic antinausea drug named ondansetron was approved. It is used to stop nausea and vomiting associated with surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy.

Did you know?

The average human gut is home to perhaps 500 to 1,000 different species of bacteria.

Did you know?

Asthma attacks and symptoms usually get started by specific triggers (such as viruses, allergies, gases, and air particles). You should talk to your doctor about these triggers and find ways to avoid or get rid of them.

Results of selective breeding for oil content in corn plants. Results of selective breeding for oil content in corn plants.
(a) Feeding by bear on salmon results in large allochthonous inputs of nutrients into (b) the forest (a) Feeding by bear on salmon results in large allochthonous inputs of nutrients into (b) the forest
New results from NASA's NEOWISE survey New results from NASA's NEOWISE survey
Comet Tempel 1 67 seconds after colliding with the Deep Impact probe. Comet Tempel 1 67 seconds after colliding with the Deep Impact probe.
If the gauge reading is now much higher than the first test results, then the cause of the low ... If the gauge reading is now much higher than the first test results, then the cause of the low ...
Selective breeding of maze-bright and maze-dull strains of rats by Tryon (1934). (Data from Cooper, ... Selective breeding of maze-bright and maze-dull strains of rats by Tryon (1934). (Data from Cooper, ...
Video: Normal and abnormal blood pH

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library