Author Question: California passed a law prohibiting any transporting of nuclear waste in the state unless the ... (Read 116 times)

melina_rosy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 531
California passed a law prohibiting any transporting of nuclear waste in the state unless the company doing so is a resident or is owned by residents of California. What constitutional issues does this law raise?

Question 2

The head of the Department of Transportation reviewed a film that demonstrated the effectiveness of air bags in automobiles. He then passed a rule that Ford Motor Company must retrofit, without charge to the automobile owner, all of its 1985 models as an experiment on the safety of the air bag. Ford refused to do so. The DOT held a hearing and decided to fine Ford 1 million for violating its regulation. A notification of this decision was mailed to Ford. What constitutional issues does this case raise?



smrtceo

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
Answer to Question 1

Regulation of the production of nuclear energy and the disposal of nuclear waste is an area that has been preempted by federal law. Nuclear waste must often be transported if it is to be effectively stored. The appropriate federal agencies have established rules and regulations. To allow the states to have control would result in a patchwork of various laws throughout the country on a matter of national concern when uniformity is desirable. The commerce clause is interpreted to give the federal government power over matters affecting the general welfare of the nation, such as the production of nuclear energy and its related activities. Consequently, this area is preempted under the supremacy clause. It would further violate the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution to allow a state to favor its local industries and discriminate against out-of-state businesses.

Answer to Question 2

Adjudicating Ford's responsibility without a chance for Ford to argue its case violates due process. Requiring Ford to spend its money to add air bags to cars it has already sold also violates due process. Further, it violates equal protection to single out Ford instead of imposing an equal obligation on the entire automobile industry. There is no reasonable basis for applying such a regulation only to Ford.



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
 

Did you know?

About 100 new prescription or over-the-counter drugs come into the U.S. market every year.

Did you know?

The largest baby ever born weighed more than 23 pounds but died just 11 hours after his birth in 1879. The largest surviving baby was born in October 2009 in Sumatra, Indonesia, and weighed an astounding 19.2 pounds at birth.

Did you know?

A strange skin disease referred to as Morgellons has occurred in the southern United States and in California. Symptoms include slowly healing sores, joint pain, persistent fatigue, and a sensation of things crawling through the skin. Another symptom is strange-looking, threadlike extrusions coming out of the skin.

Did you know?

Women are two-thirds more likely than men to develop irritable bowel syndrome. This may be attributable to hormonal changes related to their menstrual cycles.

Did you know?

Approximately one in three babies in the United States is now delivered by cesarean section. The number of cesarean sections in the United States has risen 46% since 1996.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library