If a reviewer is asking What implications do the findings have ...

[Jipu 123]

If a reviewer is asking What implications do the findings have for practice?, which phase of the research critique is represented?
 
  a. Analysis
  b. Comparison
  c. Comprehension
  d. Evaluation

Question 2

In which phase of the critical appraisal is the study compared and contrasted with the ideal, requiring that the reviewer understand each step of the research process?
 
  a. Analysis
  b. Comparison
  c. Comprehension
  d. Evaluation

[matt95]

Answer to Question 1

ANS: C
The question comes from the comprehension phase.

Answer to Question 2

ANS: B
The comparison phase requires knowledge of what each step of the research process should be like, and then that is compared with the ideal.
The analysis phase involves a critique of the logical links connecting one study element with another.
The comprehension phase requires the reviewer to thoroughly understand the study.
The evaluation phase highlights the meaning and significance of the study.

[Jipu 123]

Thank you

[matt95]

Happy to help you