Author Question: Explain what the Thirteenth and Twenty-First Amendments had in common. What will be an ideal ... (Read 45 times)

tatyanajohnson · **on:** Jul 10, 2018

Explain what the Thirteenth and Twenty-First Amendments had in common.

What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

Describe the historical development of the election of senators.

What will be an ideal response?

olderstudent · **Reply #1 on:** Jul 10, 2018

Answer to Question 1

An ideal response will:
1, Explain that the Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery and the Twenty-First Amendment repealed Prohibition.
2, Note that amendments generally avoided social and economic policy, with three exceptions: abolishing slavery, instituting a federal income tax, and prohibiting alcohol. So both the Thirteenth and Twenty-First Amendments dealt with social issues.
3, Explain that slavery and taxation were mentioned in the Constitution, so these were not new areas. But the failure of Prohibition was seen as providing good reason for social policies to be left out of the Constitution, because social norms can change.

Answer to Question 2

An ideal response will:
1, Explain the original process for selection of senatorsselection of senators by the state legislature where each senator would have one vote.
2, Discuss the Seventeenth Amendment and its process for electing senators by popular vote of the electorate in each state.