Author Question: What has Delia and Sykess marriage been like? What will be an ideal ... (Read 45 times)

altibaby

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 562
What has Delia and Sykess marriage been like?
 
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

What implications, if any, does the title Pauls Case have for this story?Is Paul mentally ill, or does Cather place the roots of his malaise elsewhere?
 
  What will be an ideal response?



6ana001

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 311
Answer to Question 1


  • Delia married out of love. Sykes, she believes, brought only lust to the union (a longing after the flesh). Two months after the wedding, he gave her the first of many brutal beatings. In town, he is notorious for beating her and she for surviving his savage assaults. Sykes has frequently disappeared to squander his irregular earnings while Delia has worked as a laundress to pay their bills. Delias hard work wounds Sykess masculine pride: it reminds him that he cannot support her. Sykes is now adulterously involved with Bertha. Delia is not surprised to discover that he is trying to kill her.



Answer to Question 2


  • Robinson has this to say about Cathers view of Paul:



As if to underscore her own intuition in regard to the story, Willa gave it the subtitle A Study in Temperament, and to the modern reader the pathological attributes of Pauls malaise are more persuasive than the romantic aspects. Willa told George Seibel that she drew on two boys who had been in her classes for the character of Paul, but to others she confessed how much of her own hunger and frustration were embodied in the unhappy boys flight from the drab reality of his daily life and in his instinctive reaching out for beauty.
In other words, we today tend to think Paul seriously disturbed, but apparently Cather didnt see him that way. In conflict with school, neighbors, and family, Paul seems to her an admirable victim. Cather often sticks up for the lonely, sensitive individual pitted against a philistine provincial societyas in her famous story The Sculptors Funeral.
Pauls Case was featured in the PBS television film series The American Short Story. It is available on video and DVD from Library Video Company at www.libraryvideo.co m. Short scenes from the script of Ron Cowens adaptation are included in The American Short Story, Volume 2 (New York: Dell, 1980), and invite comparison with the original.
A detailed plan for teaching Pauls Case is offered by Bruce E. Miller in Teaching the Art of Literature (Urbana, IL: NCTE, 1980). To get students involved in the story before they read it outside of class, Miller suggests reading passages from the early part of the story (before Paul flees to New York) and summarizing what happens, and then asking students how theyd imagine Cather would continue the story. He advises the instructor to show the class a few photographs of adolescent boys and to ask how closely the pictures reflect students mental images of Paul. The point is to spark a discussion of Pauls complex character. Is he a cheat? A victim? A hero? Various opinions are likely to emerge, and students may come to see that the different views of Paul are not necessarily incompatible with each other, and that Cather has accomplished the difficult feat of delineating a complex character who, though flawed, engages the readers sympathy.



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
 

Did you know?

Illness; diuretics; laxative abuse; hot weather; exercise; sweating; caffeine; alcoholic beverages; starvation diets; inadequate carbohydrate consumption; and diets high in protein, salt, or fiber can cause people to become dehydrated.

Did you know?

There are more nerve cells in one human brain than there are stars in the Milky Way.

Did you know?

Glaucoma is a leading cause of blindness. As of yet, there is no cure. Everyone is at risk, and there may be no warning signs. It is six to eight times more common in African Americans than in whites. The best and most effective way to detect glaucoma is to receive a dilated eye examination.

Did you know?

Human kidneys will clean about 1 million gallons of blood in an average lifetime.

Did you know?

Elderly adults are at greatest risk of stroke and myocardial infarction and have the most to gain from prophylaxis. Patients ages 60 to 80 years with blood pressures above 160/90 mm Hg should benefit from antihypertensive treatment.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library