This topic contains a solution. Click here to go to the answer

Author Question: What is a holding and what are dicta? Why is it important to distinguish between the ... (Read 36 times)

HudsonKB16

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 535
What is a holding and what are dicta?
 
  Why is it important to distinguish between the two?

Question 2

In analyzing a case, what are some guideposts a paralegal might look for and how should he make use of them?
 
  Help with this question, thanks.



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
Marked as best answer by a Subject Expert

EAN94

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 307
Answer to Question 1

When analyzing cases, one should determine which statements of the court are legally binding and which are not. Only the holding (the legal principle to be drawn from the court's decision) is binding. Other views expressed in the opinion are referred to as dicta and are not binding. Dicta is the plural of dictum. As used here, dictum is an abbreviated form of the Latin term obiter dictum, which means a remark by the way. Dicta are any statements made in a decision that go beyond the facts of the case or that do not directly relate to the facts or to the resolution of the issue being addressed. Dicta include comments used by the court to illustrate an example and statements concerning a rule of law not essential to the case. One can probably assume that statements are dicta if they begin with If the facts were different or If the plaintiff had . . . or some other if/then phrase.

Answer to Question 2

Often, the judge writing the opinion provides some guideposts, perhaps by indicating sections and subsections within the opinion by numbers, letters, or subtitles. Scanning through the opinion for these types of indicators can help orient the paralegal to the opinion's format. In cases that involve dissenting or concurring opinions, the paralegal should make sure to identify these opinions so that they are not mistaken for the majority opinion. Generally, the paralegal should scan through the case once or twice to identify its components and then read the case (or sections of the case) until he understands the facts and procedural history of the case, the issues involved, the applicable law, the legal reasoning of the court, and how the reasoning leads to the court's conclusion on the issues.




HudsonKB16

  • Member
  • Posts: 535
Reply 2 on: Aug 3, 2018
Gracias!


cdmart10

  • Member
  • Posts: 332
Reply 3 on: Yesterday
Thanks for the timely response, appreciate it

 

Did you know?

A good example of polar molecules can be understood when trying to make a cake. If water and oil are required, they will not mix together. If you put them into a measuring cup, the oil will rise to the top while the water remains on the bottom.

Did you know?

Street names for barbiturates include reds, red devils, yellow jackets, blue heavens, Christmas trees, and rainbows. They are commonly referred to as downers.

Did you know?

All adults should have their cholesterol levels checked once every 5 years. During 2009–2010, 69.4% of Americans age 20 and older reported having their cholesterol checked within the last five years.

Did you know?

Essential fatty acids have been shown to be effective against ulcers, asthma, dental cavities, and skin disorders such as acne.

Did you know?

Asthma attacks and symptoms usually get started by specific triggers (such as viruses, allergies, gases, and air particles). You should talk to your doctor about these triggers and find ways to avoid or get rid of them.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library