This topic contains a solution. Click here to go to the answer

Author Question: Identify and give an example of each of the two elements that determines whether property is ... (Read 32 times)

KimWrice

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 579
Identify and give an example of each of the two elements that determines whether property is abandoned for Fourth Amendment purposes.
 
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

Why is there no reasonable expectation of privacy in open fields? Why does the open fields doctrine apply even when owners post a No Trespassing sign?
 
  What will be an ideal response?



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
Marked as best answer by a Subject Expert

Liddy

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 342
Answer to Question 1

There are two elements to determining whether property is abandoned for Fourth
Amendment purposes: a physical and a mental element. For the physical element, a
person must physically give up possession of an item. For the mental element, a
person must intend to give up the expectation of privacy in an item.
A common example of abandoned property may be small pieces of trash. After people
eat their fast food sandwiches, they then discard the wrappers in which the sandwiches
came by throwing them away. They have both physically given up possession of the
wrapper and did so with the intent to abandon any expectation of privacy in it.

Answer to Question 2

For a property to fall within the category of open fields where there is no
reasonable expectation of privacy, these areas must not provide settings for the
intimate activities that the Fourth Amendment was designed to protect from
government interference or surveillance. The Fourth Amendment protects people in
their persons, houses, papers, and effects.. Thus, even looking at the Amendment in
a pure textual sense, it is easy to see that it was not meant to protect open, privatelyowned land.
Posting a No Trespassing sign does not mean that the open field doctrine may not
apply and exclude the posted property from protection of the Fourth Amendment. The
Supreme Court has decided that if this was all that was needed to give owners a
reasonable expectation of privacy in an area where they could not otherwise expect
such, police officers would have to guess before every search as to whether owners
have posted a sufficient number of warnings or posted them in adequate places to
protect the property. This would make the job of the police very difficult, as they must
be able to know with a reasonable degree of certainty what is protected by the Fourth
Amendment and what is not.





 

Did you know?

In 1886, William Bates reported on the discovery of a substance produced by the adrenal gland that turned out to be epinephrine (adrenaline). In 1904, this drug was first artificially synthesized by Friedrich Stolz.

Did you know?

Patients who have been on total parenteral nutrition for more than a few days may need to have foods gradually reintroduced to give the digestive tract time to start working again.

Did you know?

When intravenous medications are involved in adverse drug events, their harmful effects may occur more rapidly, and be more severe than errors with oral medications. This is due to the direct administration into the bloodstream.

Did you know?

Every 10 seconds, a person in the United States goes to the emergency room complaining of head pain. About 1.2 million visits are for acute migraine attacks.

Did you know?

The average adult has about 21 square feet of skin.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library