Author Question: Compare and contrast Lewinsohn's explanation of major depression with Seligman's attribution-learned ... (Read 64 times)

saraeharris

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 546
Compare and contrast Lewinsohn's explanation of major depression with Seligman's attribution-learned helplessness approach.
 
  What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

Research exploring the relationship between genetics and eating disorders suggests that ____.
 
  a. there is a strong genetic link for eating disorders
 b. there is a strong genetic link for anorexia and bulimia, but not for other eating disorders
 c. there is only a weak link between genetics and eating disorders
 d. although there is strong support for a connection between genetic and biological factors with eating disorders, more research is needed to determine the relationship



mammy1697

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 341
Answer to Question 1

Lewinsohn and his colleagues developed a behavioral explanation for depression. This model suggests that a lack of reinforcements leads to feelings of depression. The lack of reinforcement can occur for reasons external to the person or can be an outgrowth of reduced activity. Either way, the depressed person engages in fewer and fewer actions that can be reinforced, so a downward spiral of negative emotions and reduced activity continues. In addition, the sympathy of others may inadvertently reward the depressed person for inaction, so the depression deepens further. Depressed individuals are seen as having weak social skillsthey initiate few conversations, smile less, and complain more, therefore reducing their ability to obtain reinforcement. Lewinsohn's model also indicates that prior to being depressed, individuals who experience major stresses may feel that they can no longer predict their world and, feeling they can no longer control events, become more self-critical. As self-awareness of inadequacy intensifies, the person functions less appropriately and feels less self-confident and more depressed. Therefore, in addition to strictly operant (stimulus-response-consequence) components, this model includes the cognitive and emotional elements of depression.

In Seligman's model of depression, thoughts and feelings of helplessness are learned and depression results from learned helplessnessan acquired belief that one is helpless and unable to affect outcomes in one's life. According to Seligman, people who feel helpless make causal attributions, or speculations about why they are helpless. Individuals who are depressed mistakenly generalize this view to other, controllable situations. Thus, depression is seen as a form of learned helplessness. Depressed individuals make depressive attributions and feel less in control of their lives. Attribution style focuses on the misperception of causes of negative events rather than the awareness of inadequacy. Seligman and his colleagues argue that depressives are pessimists: they see the causes of negative events as due to internal factors (them) and stable traits (rather than ones that can change with time or situation) and as affecting global rather than specific spheres of their lives.

In general, Lewinsohn and Seligman share common ground in assuming that a lack of activity and a belief in lost control are the keys to depression. However, Lewinsohn emphasizes the behavioral deficiencies of people prone to depression, while Seligman points out the attributional (cognitive) deficiencies.

Answer to Question 2

d



Related Topics

Need homework help now?

Ask unlimited questions for free

Ask a Question
 

Did you know?

When blood is deoxygenated and flowing back to the heart through the veins, it is dark reddish-blue in color. Blood in the arteries that is oxygenated and flowing out to the body is bright red. Whereas arterial blood comes out in spurts, venous blood flows.

Did you know?

Approximately 25% of all reported medication errors result from some kind of name confusion.

Did you know?

Adult head lice are gray, about ? inch long, and often have a tiny dot on their backs. A female can lay between 50 and 150 eggs within the several weeks that she is alive. They feed on human blood.

Did you know?

It is believed that the Incas used anesthesia. Evidence supports the theory that shamans chewed cocoa leaves and drilled holes into the heads of patients (letting evil spirits escape), spitting into the wounds they made. The mixture of cocaine, saliva, and resin numbed the site enough to allow hours of drilling.

Did you know?

The cure for trichomoniasis is easy as long as the patient does not drink alcoholic beverages for 24 hours. Just a single dose of medication is needed to rid the body of the disease. However, without proper precautions, an individual may contract the disease repeatedly. In fact, most people develop trichomoniasis again within three months of their last treatment.

For a complete list of videos, visit our video library