Author Question: Discuss the pros and cons of labeling a child with a significant mental health disorder. What ... (Read 94 times)

darbym82 · **on:** Jun 22, 2018

Discuss the pros and cons of labeling a child with a significant mental health disorder.

What will be an ideal response?

Question 2

In the Thom et al. (2000) study of the treatment of dental-phobic patients, if participants in the two experimental groups showed reduced anxiety from pretest to posttest, could the researchers conclude that the treatments were effective in reducing anxiety?

a. Yes. Reduction in anxiety for the experimental groups would prove the effectiveness of the treatment.
b. No. There are many possible reasons why patients would show reduced anxiety, so the only way to know if the cause was the treatments would be to use a control group that did not get a treatment.
c. Yes, but only if one of the groups had a greater reduction in anxiety than the other.
d. No. To conclude that the treatments were effective, they would need to see if the effects last for many years afterwards.

GCabra · **Reply #1 on:** Jun 22, 2018

Answer to Question 1

Pros name; access to services; research support; access to education about the disorder; support from others who have children with similar disorders; validate family's experiences with the child
Cons assumes all children with same disorder are the same; detracts from the individual; diminishes individual's areas of competence; problems may be transient and not warrant a diagnosis
Child is not the disorder

Answer to Question 2

B